Dyscalculia is a specific learning disability affecting a person’s ability to understand numbers and perform mathematical operations.
Often called “number blindness” or “dyslexia for numbers,” these labels oversimplify the condition. Dyscalculia stems from brain-based differences, especially in the left parietal lobe, and is lifelong, affecting both children and adults in areas such as time management, money, directions, and sequencing.
We specialize in helping children overcome the symptoms of dyslexia. Book a free consultation to discuss your child’s learning needs.
Common difficulties
People with dyscalculia may struggle with:
- Estimation
- Short- and long-term memory (especially for number facts)
- Telling time
- Understanding numerical quantity
- Handling money
- Performing calculations
- Sequencing and pattern recognition
- Spatial orientation and direction
These challenges persist despite average or above-average ability in other areas. Difficulties with math are not always due to dyscalculia; they may stem from general learning challenges, poor instruction, or anxiety.
Definitions and prevalence
Although definitions vary, common themes include:
- A severe, specific, and persistent difficulty in mathematics
- In contrast with generally strong performance in other academic areas
- Often hereditary
Dyscalculia affects approximately 6% of the population, equally among males and females. It can occur alongside other conditions like dyslexia, dyspraxia, and ADHD, but is neurologically distinct.
Causes of dyscalculia
Several factors may contribute to dyscalculia:
- Genetics: Dyscalculia often runs in families.
- Brain structure: MRI scans show differences in brain volume and surface area.
- Environment: Factors like prematurity or prenatal exposure to alcohol.
- Working memory issues: Difficulties in holding and manipulating numbers.
Types and subtypes
Dyscalculia is not a one-size-fits-all condition but includes various subtypes:
- Core number: Poor number sense, estimation, place value understanding.
- Reasoning: Difficulty grasping relationships like part-whole, inverse operations.
- Memory: Trouble recalling number facts and sequences.
- Visual-spatial: Struggling with symbols, graphs, number lines, or geometric shapes.
Strategies for each subtype include using manipulatives, visual aids, verbalization, and real-life contexts.
Differentiating dyscalculia
It’s important to distinguish between:
- Developmental dyscalculia (a neurological condition)
- Math learning difficulties (caused by gaps or instruction)
- Pseudo-dyscalculia (math anxiety)
- Acalculia (loss of mathematical ability after brain injury)
Indicators of dyscalculia
Signs include:
- Inability to subitize (instantly recognize small quantities)
- Weak number sense and estimation skills
- Reliance on inefficient strategies (e.g., drawing 137 dots to solve 137 + 78)
- Trouble with sequencing, pattern recognition, and counting backward
- Difficulty with money, time, and place value
- Misinterpretation of math symbols
- Persistent errors in calculations, e.g., 1/5 + 2/3 = 3/8
Subitizing and number sense
Subitizing is recognizing small quantities instantly (e.g., seeing 3 dots without counting). Students with dyscalculia often fail to subitize, requiring them to count each item individually.
Number sense refers to understanding relationships between numbers. A student with good number sense might simplify 29 + 30 + 31 to 3 × 30. Students with dyscalculia may rely only on rote methods, making math harder than it needs to be.
Identification tools
Early identification is crucial. However, children develop at different rates, so diagnosis should be cautious, particularly in the early years.
Identification tools include:
1. Checklists
These screen for common difficulties (e.g., trouble with place value or estimation). While quick, they are subjective.
2. Observation and error analysis
Watching a child work through problems can reveal patterns in misconceptions and highlight whether difficulties are due to dyscalculia or other causes.
3. Screening tools
- Dyscalculia Screener: Ages 6–14, online, evaluates number sense and calculation.
- Dynamo Maths Profiler: Ages 6–9, generates detailed reports on performance and number sense.
- DysCalculiUM: For teens and adults, assesses six numerical domains.
4. Inchworms vs. grasshoppers
Steve Chinn describes two math styles:
- Inchworms: Students rely on memorized procedures, are detail-oriented and inflexible
- Grasshoppers: Students estimate, generalize, and adjust numbers flexibly
Most dyscalculics are inchworms. Teaching styles and tools should be adapted accordingly.
5. Informal assessment
Books like The Maths and Dyscalculia Assessment offer step-by-step evaluations and provide essential information for formulating effective teaching intervention plans.
6. Full diagnostic assessment
This is done by educational psychologists using standardized IQ, working memory, and numeracy tests. These are formal but useful for exam accommodations.
Math anxiety and its impact
Math anxiety is a learned emotional response to negative experiences with math. It can cause:
- Physical symptoms (sweating, racing heart, tension)
- Psychological symptoms (panic, helplessness, avoidance)
It’s critical to distinguish between dyscalculia and math anxiety. Not all anxious students have dyscalculia, but all dyscalculics will experience some level of math anxiety.
Causes of math anxiety
- Negative past experiences (e.g., embarrassment in class)
- Unrealistic expectations (emphasis on speed and accuracy)
- Poor teaching methods (rote learning, lack of explanation)
- Cultural and parental attitudes (“I was bad at math too”)
- Test pressure and comparison (timed tests, visible scoreboards)
Identifying anxiety in class
Look for:
- Refusal to engage
- Freezing on simple problems
- Asking others to calculate (e.g., splitting bills)
- Negative self-talk (“I’m just bad at math”)
Reducing anxiety and supporting learning
To support anxious or dyscalculic students:
- Create a safe classroom environment
- Avoid timed tests
- Emphasize understanding, not speed
- Celebrate mistakes as learning opportunities
- Use multi-sensory teaching: combine visual, auditory, and kinesthetic methods
- Build number sense early and revisit often
- Use concrete materials (like Cuisenaire rods, base ten blocks)
- Foster metacognition: help learners reflect on their thinking
Conclusion
Dyscalculia is a complex, multifaceted condition that significantly affects a student’s ability to engage with mathematics. Dyscalculia is distinct from general math difficulty or anxiety but often coexists with them. Understanding the signs, using targeted strategies, and identifying the correct type of support can dramatically improve outcomes.
